BUG (Bivalue Universal Grave)
When every cell but one has two candidates.
A BUG — Bivalue Universal Grave — is a board state where every unsolved cell has exactly two candidates. Such a board always has either zero or at least two solutions, so a proper puzzle can never reach it.
The useful case is BUG+1: every unsolved cell has two candidates except one cell with three. That third candidate is what keeps the puzzle from being a BUG, so it must be the answer for that cell.
If all unsolved cells have two candidates except one cell with three, place the digit that appears three times in that cell’s row, column or box.
How to spot it
- Late in the solve, check whether all remaining cells are bivalue except one.
- In the three-candidate cell, find the digit that appears three times (instead of twice) in its row, column and box.
- That digit is the solution for the cell.
Why it works
In a BUG, every candidate appears exactly twice in each house, so the digits can be swapped in pairs and there is more than one solution. Removing the extra candidate would create that situation. A unique puzzle doesn’t allow it, so the extra candidate must be the true digit.
Example from a real puzzle
This position comes from one of Sudoku Desk’s Expert daily puzzles, at the moment the BUG (Bivalue Universal Grave) is the next logical step. Small grey digits are the remaining candidates.
- Key candidates
- 5Given
- 5Solved so far
- BUG applies when the board is reduced so that every unsolved cell has exactly two candidates — except one cell with three. Here that cell is R4C1 (5, 8, 9).
- If that extra candidate were removed too, every remaining digit would have an even number of spots in every row, column and box — which would let the puzzle have two solutions. A proper puzzle has only one.
- So the extra candidate must be the answer. The digit that appears three times in R4C1’s row is 9 (not 5 or 8) — therefore R4C1 must be 9.
Open this position in Sudoku DeskCandidates are filled in. Find the BUG (Bivalue Universal Grave) yourself, or press 💡 for a step-by-step hint.
Practise it
Your turn. Each puzzle below has a BUG (Bivalue Universal Grave) waiting to be found. Tap the cell, pick the digit, and you’ll see straight away if you’re right. Stuck? Take a hint.
Tips
- Your pencil marks must be complete and correct for BUG to be safe. Use Auto pencilmarks to check.